As 
Matt Reynolds sat on the New York Mets  bench Thursday evening for Game 5 of the National League Championship  series waiting to make his major league debut, one man that can relate  to his angst is 
Chet Trail.  Placed on the New York Yankees World Series roster in 1964, Trail is  the only player ever on a postseason roster never to appear in a major  league game.
  | 
| Chet Trail / Baseball-Birthdays.com | 
The Yankees signed Trail in 1962 out of Libbey High School in Toledo, Ohio, where he was a standout multi-sport start. 
The Yankees gave Trail a $43,000 bonus,  and in 1963 they assigned him to their Fort Lauderdale team in the  Florida State League. One year later, in only his second professional  season, the Yankees placed him on their World Series roster after Tony  Kubek was injured; however, the acclaim wasn’t as glamorous as it  seemed.
“The Yankees didn’t call me up,” the 71-year-old Trail said from his  home in Toledo on Thursday evening. “It was a paper move protecting me  by calling me up on the roster. They told me they were going to put me  on the roster, but they didn’t go any further as to what their plans  were as far as bringing me up.”
Barely 20-years-old, Trail was excited to be named to the club; however, he would have enjoyed it more if he was in uniform with the  rest of the Yankees legends. Trail watched the World Series from his home  in Ohio while attending college classes.
“I was just thrilled to be privileged enough to be on the roster, so I  didn’t expect any more,” he said. “I was just happy to be on the  roster, but I came back home and went back to college.”
The Yankees lost in seven games to the St. Louis Cardinals, but in  true Yankee fashion, they cut Trail in on a share of the runner-ups  earnings even though he never stepped foot in the dugout. It’s something he appreciates over fifty years later.
“If I can remember, I did get a nominal sum being on that roster,” he  said. “Back then I think the players voted for shares, but if I can  remember, I did get something just for being on the roster.”
The culmination of the 1964 season left Trail with many unanswered  questions. In spring training, he was promised that he would get a look  at the major league level, but it never materialized.
“In 1964, Archie Moore and I were supposed to split half of a season  in which I was to play in A-ball half a season and go up to the Yankees,  and he was to come down and play, but they never did that,” he said. “I  stayed the whole year in Greensboro, but they brought me up by name  only. I never got an explanation as to why physically that never  happened.”
Trail spent seven seasons in the minor leagues, reaching as high as  Triple-A. He went to major league spring training five times, but for  various reasons, he didn’t make the cut. Despite never reaching the  major leagues, Trail had the fortune of spending time around the old  guard of the Yankees dynasty.
“I was kind of awe struck with Mantle, Maris, Berra, Howard, Kubek,  Richardson, and Pepitone,” he said. “I am 18-19 years old, and to be on  the field in spring training with people like that who I grew up  idolizing was a great experience.”
After finishing his baseball career in 1969, Trail worked in the  insurance field, became a church pastor, and was one of the most  successful high school basketball referees in Ohio. He is currently  using his position as a respected Pastor in the community to revitalize  the site of his old high school, by lobbying to build a sports complex  where it once stood. After some meetings with local officials, Trail is  proud with the progress he is making.
“Along with the chamber of commerce we’re putting together a business  plan, so we’re making headway with that,” he said. “I’m really looking  forward to bring that to fruition; I think we will. It’s been two years  and it’s finally coming together. I’ve contacted Major League Baseball’s  RBI program for a grant and as soon as our leg work with the business  part of it is done, we’ll be reaching out to actually getting money and  making the complex come to pass.”
Trail hopes that Reynolds, the Mets young shortstop gets his  opportunity to play in a major league game whether it is during this  year’s playoffs or next year’s regular season. He doesn’t want Reynolds  to experience a similar fate searching for answers for a half-century.
“In all my years, now I’m 71, I never quite understood what actually  happened there,” he said. “I was never told and it wasn’t explained to  me. I had to do well in the minor leagues just to be put on the roster,  but I never quite got over that hump.”