In 2011, while milling around the hotel where the Yankees Old Timers were stationed for the weekend, I encountered Arroyo sitting in an almost regal manner in a chair in the corner of the lobby, free from the rush of the crowds that swarmed the other alumni making their way through the hotel en route to explore New York City. While the droves of fans and collectors flocked to the younger retired Yankees, I sensed an opportunity to talk with Arroyo about his vast treasure of experiences as a ballplayer in Puerto Rico in the late 1940s with all of the legendary Negro League and Puerto Rican stars who passed through the famed winter league.
|Luis Arroyo (r.) with the author in 2011 / N. Diunte|
|Photo of Arroyo with Ponce in Puerto Rico / N. Diunte|
“I could name you the best hitter ever to come out of winter ball — Frank Coimbre,” Arroyo said in 2011. “He didn’t get a chance to play because he was colored. He was the best hitter in Puerto Rico and I could bet you anything that he could hit in the big leagues. He could run, throw, and hit. He was a hell of a ballplayer.”
As our conversation progressed, the then 84-year-old Arroyo said that he was tired from the travel and wouldn’t be attending the team’s evening festivities at a local restaurant. He then proceeded to show me his tickets and offer them to me as he didn’t want them to go to waste. I surely couldn’t turn down an opportunity to have a good meal and meet some more of the Yankees alumni.
|Old Timers Day Reception Pass / N. Diunte|
|David Wells (l.) and the author at Yankees alumni party / N. Diunte|
|Arroyo (l.) with Fidel Castro (r.) in 1959 as a member of the Havana team / N. Diunte|
“When I had that good year, [finishing] 15-5, and we won the World Series, I used to pitch all year around,” he said. “When I finished the World Series in 1961, the GM Roy Hamey said to stop pitching all year around. I told him that I pitch winter ball because I wasn’t making any money. He took care of me. He gave me $10,000.”
|Photo of Arroyo pitching that is outside of the Yankees suites / N. Diunte|
“I made a mistake,” he lamented. “When I wasn’t pitching, instead of going to the ballpark and keep running and doing some throwing, I went out with all the friends, drank, and ate, and when I came to spring training, I was 20 pounds overweight; it was the biggest mistake of my life. I don’t blame him, he did me a favor. When I gained all those pounds, I couldn’t throw at all. In 1963, I hurt my arm. … I went to bed and I felt something to my elbow and that was the end of my career. I had an operation. I tried to play winter ball and I couldn’t do it.”
While his arm injury spelled the end of Arroyo’s playing career with the Yankees, he remained with them as a scout for 20 years. He was instrumental in getting them to sign Ricky Ledee, Jorge Posada, and Bernie Williams, the latter for which he told me how he had to work hard on George Steinbrenner to convince him to go after a skinny 16-year-old outfielder from Puerto Rico.
As he prepared to move on with the rest of his day, he called down his grandson Gustavo from his hotel room. As he emerged from the elevator, he was holding an envelope. Arroyo introduced me to his grandson and proceeded to take a ticket and special pass from the envelope. He wanted me to be their guest at Old Timers Day. He said that he thought it was something that I would enjoy as a baseball fan and instructed me to meet them at the hotel at 9AM for breakfast the next morning.
|2011 Old Timers Day Suite Ticket / N. Diunte|
|A small sampling of the decor in the suites / N. Diunte|
|Arroyo's entrance on the big screen at Yankee Stadium / N. Diunte|
|Autographed photo of Ford and Arroyo / N. Diunte|
|Moose Skowron (r.) with the author in 2011 / N. Diunte|
“Even though I have arthritis in my knees, I can’t miss it.”